This is the recipe I reach for when I want comfort in cookie form: soft, tender, and impossibly peanut-buttery. I discovered this version during a late-night baking experiment when I swapped a typical equal-butter-and-peanut-butter ratio for double the peanut butter. The result was transformative—cookies that stay soft for days, have intense peanut flavor, and melt on the tongue. I remember serving a fresh batch at a small neighborhood gathering; people asked for the recipe and then requested more the next week. That kind of reaction convinced me to write it down and share it.

What makes these cookies special is the texture. They are not crisp edges and dry middles—these are pillowy, slightly chewy, with a tender crumb that gives under your bite. The extra peanut butter keeps them moist and rich, while a small amount of butter adds structure and a gentle lift. These cookies are ideal when you want something nostalgic, easy to make, and reliably delicious. I recommend enjoying one warm with a tall glass of milk; it's one of those small pleasures that brightens any afternoon.

Ingredients

• Butter (1/2 cup / 1 stick): Use unsalted butter so you control the seasoning; it provides structure and a touch of richness without overwhelming the peanut flavor. European-style butter works fine but is not necessary.
• Granulated sugar (1/2 cup) and brown sugar (1/2 cup packed): The mix of sugars balances sweetness and chew—brown sugar adds moisture and a subtle molasses note that keeps the cookies soft.
• Peanut butter (1 cup + 2 tablespoons): Use jarred, stabilized peanut butter (for example Jif or Skippy). Avoid natural peanut butter that separates; this recipe relies on the consistent fat distribution in regular jarred peanut butter.
• Egg (1 large): Provides lift and binds the dough; bring it to room temperature for better incorporation and consistent texture.
• Vanilla (1 1/2 teaspoons): Enhances the peanut notes and rounds out flavor—use pure vanilla extract when possible.
• All-purpose flour (1 1/3 cups, spooned and leveled): Spoon into the measuring cup and level with a knife for accurate measurement; too much flour makes cookies dry, too little makes them spread more.
• Baking soda (1/2 teaspoon) and baking powder (1/2 teaspoon): Combined leaveners create a gentle lift without making the cookies cakey.
• Kosher salt (1/4 teaspoon): Balances sweetness and brightens the peanut flavor.
• Extra granulated sugar for rolling (1/2 cup): Creates a thin sweet shell and makes the traditional fork crosshatch easier to press.

Instructions

Prepare Mixing: Preheat your oven to 350°F (177°C) when you're ready to bake. In a large bowl or stand mixer fitted with a paddle, beat 1/2 cup (1 stick) of butter on medium until smooth and creamy, about 1–2 minutes. Scrape the bowl to ensure even creaming. Cream Sugars: Add 1/2 cup granulated sugar and 1/2 cup packed brown sugar. Beat until light and fluffy, about 2–3 minutes, scraping the sides. Proper creaming incorporates air that helps the cookies rise slightly and gives a tender texture. Add Peanut Butter: Mix in 1 cup plus 2 tablespoons peanut butter (I prefer Jif). Beat until fully combined. If using crunchy peanut butter, mix a little longer to evenly distribute the pieces. Incorporate Egg and Vanilla: Add 1 large egg and 1 1/2 teaspoons vanilla extract. Beat until homogeneous. The egg is the main binder—do not skip or substitute with a watery egg replacer. Combine Dry Ingredients: Spoon 1 1/3 cups all-purpose flour into the bowl without stirring. Sprinkle 1/2 teaspoon baking soda, 1/2 teaspoon baking powder, and 1/4 teaspoon kosher salt on top. Stir the dry ingredients lightly with a spoon to distribute them before turning the mixer on. Mix Until Just Combined: Turn the mixer on low and mix until the dough comes together and flour streaks disappear. Stop before overmixing—overworking develops gluten and produces tough cookies. The dough should be cohesive and slightly soft. Chill the Dough: Cover and chill for at least 15 minutes to an hour (or up to 2 days). Chilling firms the dough, makes it easier to scoop, and helps flavors meld. You can skip chilling if pressed for time, but the dough will be softer to handle. Shape and Sugar: Line baking sheets with parchment or silicone mats. Use a 1 1/2-inch cookie scoop to portion dough into balls—do not smooth by hand; preserve the textured surface. Roll each ball in about 1/2 cup granulated sugar to coat, then place on the sheet about 1" apart—the dough doesn’t spread much. Fork Press: Dip a fork in sugar and press into the top of each cookie, then turn the fork perpendicular and press once more to make a crosshatch. Press to your preferred thickness: about 1/2" yields the soft, slightly puffy cookie I love. Bake: Bake at 350°F for 10–12 minutes. Cookies are done when edges are set and centers are no longer shiny. For very soft cookies, err on the shorter side—pull them before any browning occurs. They will set as they cool. Finish and Cool: Immediately sprinkle with a little extra granulated sugar after removing from the oven. Let cookies rest on the pan for about 5 minutes before transferring to a wire rack to cool completely. Enjoy warm with milk!

Storage Tips

Store cooled cookies in an airtight container at room temperature for up to three days to maintain the soft texture. Insert a slice of bread into the container to help retain moisture if you plan to keep them longer—replace the bread every day to prevent mold. For longer storage, freeze baked cookies in a single layer on a tray, then transfer to a freezer bag for up to three months. Reheat frozen cookies briefly in a 300°F oven for 3–5 minutes to recapture that fresh-baked warmth and softness.

Ingredient Substitutions

If you prefer a nut-free alternative, swap peanut butter for a sunflower seed butter (such as SunButter) and reduce baking time slightly as seed butters can brown faster. If you must use natural peanut butter, stir it thoroughly to reincorporate oils; know that dough will be slightly looser and may spread more. For a gluten-free option, use a 1-to-1 gluten-free flour blend—expect a small texture change but generally good results. You can replace the egg with a flax egg for egg-free diets, but cookies may be less tender.

Serving Suggestions

Serve warm with whole milk or a milk alternative for dunking. These cookies pair nicely with chocolate-dipped strawberries or a scoop of vanilla ice cream for a seasonal dessert. For a party platter, alternate cookies with small squares of salted dark chocolate to balance the sweetness. Garnish with a light sprinkle of flaky sea salt on a few cookies to create a sweet-salty contrast that elevates the peanut flavor.

Cultural Background

Peanut butter cookies are a classic American treat with roots in simple home baking. They emerged as peanut butter became a pantry staple in the early 20th century, prized for its protein and affordability. The iconic crisscross fork marks were originally practical—flattening dense dough so it would bake evenly—and have since become a signature look. This version amplifies the peanut component, leaning into the nostalgic, mid-century American cookie tradition while focusing on modern texture preferences.

Seasonal Adaptations

In autumn, fold in 1/2 cup chopped roasted peanuts and a pinch of cinnamon for a cozy twist. For summer, add 1/3 cup mini chocolate chips just before baking for a peanut-butter-and-chocolate combination that’s always popular. Holiday versions can be sandwiched with marshmallow fluff or lightly spiced with ginger and nutmeg for festive warmth. Small changes in add-ins and spices make this base recipe adaptable for any season.

Meal Prep Tips

For make-ahead convenience, portion the dough with a scoop, roll each ball in sugar, press with a fork, and freeze on a baking sheet. Once frozen, transfer to a zipper bag and bake from frozen, adding 1–3 minutes to the bake time. This method yields consistent cookies whenever you need them. Label bags with the bake time and date to stay organized—baking a few minutes longer from frozen gives a slightly crisp edge while keeping the center soft.

These cookies are a celebration of simple ingredients and thoughtful technique: double the peanut butter, a short chill, and careful baking are the little details that make a big difference. Share them, freeze them, and make them your own.